Should You Judge a Song by its Cover?

It perplexes teenagers when their parents knowbeen interpreted with a beauty that’s almost
all the words to the latest songs. Of course,agonizing by Canadian pianist and jazz singer Diana
anyone over a certain age will realize that a highKrall. She said, “The greatest thing about
percentage of ‘new’ music, isn’t newmusic is putting it out there for people to figure
at all. It’s just new to the younger ear.out. You want the listener to find the song on
Some Like It, Some Don’ttheir own. If you give too much away, it takes
Cover version of songs have long been theaway from the imagination.” Krall is married to
subject of controversy. Some people hold thesinger/songwriter Elvis Costello, himself no
original editions in such high esteem it almoststranger to performing other’s songs, despite
resembles worship. Such devotees, who can’tbeing notoriously skilled at creating his own
bear to hear a reworking of a song, can getmaterial. His performance of Roy Orbison’s
overzealous about what they see as theirLove Hurts with Emmy Lou Harris is just one of a
sacrosanct favorites. There was many a Led Zepplethora of renditions that that particular song has
fan who found Rolf Harris’sbeen subject to.
didgeridoo-assisted adaptation of Stairway toArtists who have covered Love Hurts include:
Heaven painful to hear, while others expressed a• Joan Jett
liking for it. To each his own, eh! Ours is not to• Heart
wonder why.• Nazareth
More recently we’ve seen original artists• Cher
perform ‘their’ songs as covers with newA Good Thing?
singers or bands. One of the latest examples ofThose who are adamant that the old way is the
this is Elton John’s collaboration with rappersbest way might change their way of thinking by
DJ Ironik and Chipmunk. Their rendition oflooking at cover version as tributes. Surely no
Elton’s original song Tiny Dancer (lyrics bynew artist would contemplate an old song unless
Bernie Taupin) is well received by a great manythey felt a deep connection with it and an
young people who have no idea that it firstadmiration for it. There is something refreshing
appeared on Elton’s album Madman Acrossabout remixes and re-workings of original material.
the Water in 1971.Maybe adding orchestral instruments or other
Unique Coversmusical instruments. Often a new take births new
When a song is entirely taken over by a newinterest in the original performers too.
performer without the input, as in the aboveMusic has an evolutionary quality about it, like
case, of the original artist, it can take on a freshlanguage, it is as ever-changing as human trends
identity. Joni Mitchell’s A Case of You hasand as a result will always chime in with them.