Music & Citizenship: Can Playing a Musical Instrument Help Your Child Become a Better Citizen?

p>Disregard the popular image of rappers withparticipated in arts programs in selected
their ghetto blasters, terrorizing neighborhoodselementary and middle schools in New York City
with eardrum-splitting cacophony. Consider insteadshowed significant increases in self-esteem and
our delightful school bands and orchestras... andthinking skills.
ponder on whether those students might beThe results of studies such as these are
becoming our best future citizens.promising for the future of our society, especially
Unlikely as it may seem, recent scientific researchin the light of a 2003 Gallup Poll Survey showing
suggests this hypothesis might actually be true. Itrecord numbers of Americans now play musical
appears studying music can, in fact, impact theinstruments.
development of the human personality, especiallyThis survey - conducted by the Gallup
in the area of socialization. In particular, musicOrganization (commissioned by NAMM, the
education encourages self-discipline and diligence,National Association of Music Merchants) - found
traits which carry over into other areas.that Americans are playing musical instruments at
According to statistics compiled by the Nationalthe highest levels since 1978.
Data Resource Center, students who can beJust over half, (54 percent), of households
classified as 'disruptive' (based on factors such assurveyed had a member who plays a musical
frequent skipping of classes, times in trouble,instrument. And in 48 percent of households
in-school suspensions, disciplinary reasons given,where at least one person played an instrument,
arrests, and drop-outs) total 12.14 percent of thethere were two or more additional members who
total school population. In contrast, only 8.08also played.
percent of students involved in music classesNinety-seven percent of respondents agreed that
meet the same criteria as 'disruptive'.playing a musical instrument provides a sense of
Neurobiologist Norman Weinberger reports onaccomplishment and encourages expression, and
another research study by Martin Gardiner of85 percent believe it makes someone smarter.
Brown University. According to Weinberger,An equal number regretted not learning to play an
writing in the Winter 2000 Issue of MuSICAinstrument and 67 percent said they would still like
Research Notes, Gardiner's study checked theto learn.
relationship between arrest records of teenagersInterestingly, the survey also showed that an
and their degree of involvement in music. Heincreasing number of young people are becoming
analyzed a large-scale data base that includedinvolved in music, with the percentage of people
information gathered over a period of manyages of 5 to 17 who play an instrument at 31
years for more than a thousand residents ofpercent, up from 25 percent in 1985.
Rhode Island.Of the total respondents a further 27 percent
Gardiner tracked people from birth through thewere between the ages of 18 to 24.
age of thirty, and found that the greater theMost of those questioned began their music
involvement in music, the lower the arrest record.education before their teens with 64 percent
Teens who had music education were less likelysaying they started music study between the
to get into trouble than students who didn't.ages of 5 to 11 and 18 percent between the ages
However, those who were also involved in playingof 12 to 14.
a musical instrument had even fewer brushesIn his highly acclaimed book, A Users Guide to the
with the law. Those who had the mostBrain, Ratey John J, MD notes: "The musician is
experience, including good sight-reading ability, hadconstantly adjusting decisions on tempo, style,
a negligible arrest record.rhythm, phrasing and feeling - training the brain to
Gardiner's study, which took place in 2000, isbecome incredibly good at organizing and
backed by others. The National Association forconducting numerous activities at once. Dedicated
Music Education publishes a fact sheet on itspractice of this orchestration can have a great
website which quotes the Texas Commission onpayoff for lifelong attention skills, intelligence and
Drug and Alcohol Abuse Report. According to thean ability for self-knowledge and expression."
January 1998 report, secondary students whoGood citizens require many of these same skills in
participated in band or orchestra reported theorder to live harmoniously with other human
lowest lifetime - and current - use of allbeings. So as you move to a new town or take
substances (alcohol, tobacco and illicit drugs).up a new job, it could just be worth enquiring if
And a 1990 study at the National Arts Educationyour neighbors and colleagues are musicians.
Research Center, concluded that students who